Carbon Dioxide Capture, Utilization & Sequestration Technical Section

 View Only

Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

  • 1.  Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-17-2023 10:26 PM

    Good day all,

    We are designing well completion for the CCUS project which is the first of its kind in the country/ company. Recommendations are appreciated on the areas which need to be addressed. A few questions are:

    Can well be completed with Carbon Steel, in case there is no moisture (dehydrated gas)
    How vital is PVT data, although it is, if not available what can be done

    The wellbore hydraulic model was created and a significant increase was noticed in the gas rate with a 100 psi increase in the injection pressure. What could be the possible reason? Phase changes??

    Tubing Size                    Injection Pressure (Psi)                             Injection Rate (MMscfd)
        3-1/2"                                     1400                                                                   4
        3-1/2"                                     1500                                                                   12
        3-1/2"                                     1600                                                                   19

    What other considerations are important for designing the well completion for CCUS.

    Regards,



  • 2.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-18-2023 12:57 AM

    Hi Sahir,

    Think about a corrosion triangle of CO2, water, and carbon steel: you can only have two. The main issue with water is that you can have flow back whenever injection stops, which will start water circulation at the bottom of your well. If you can actively and reliably control this inflow, then carbon steel can be a solution.
    A second scenario is loss of integrity in your completion and CO2 bubbling into the A annulus.

    As for the hydraulic model, you are always injecting above critical pressure (1090 psi or thereabouts) so CO2 is in its dense phase at the wellhead. Unless friction losses are large, much larger than the hydrostatic head, you should have dense phase along the whole tubing. Can you plot density vs. depth?
    However, this is true for pure CO2: contaminants complicate the picture and shift dense phase conditions towards higher pressures. Which brings us to the point that CO2 equations of state (EoS) used in simulation software may not be too accurate.
    Is PVT data necessary? Not if your CO2 stream is almost pure. But you need to ensure that the right EoS and transport properties (viscosity and thermal conductivity) are used in your models.

    Best regards,



    ------------------------------
    Matteo Loizzo
    Well integrity consultant
    matteo.loizzo@mac.com
    Berlin, Germany
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-19-2023 11:23 PM

    Thank you Loizzo




  • 4.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-18-2023 04:31 AM

    Hi Sahir - Every CCS campaign is different based on composition of captured CO2, type of reservoir, conditioning of CO2 prior to injection, costs involved, permitting and well classification regulations of the territory and corrossion prediction due to impurities and batch injection scenarios. Phase change and Joule thomson effect is being considered. 
    I would highly recommend having a consultant onboard. Let me know if you need help. Meeting them next week in University of Houston at CCUS-2023. 




  • 5.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-18-2023 05:57 AM

    Oumer - You are correct, every CCS campaign is different. I will also be attending the University of Houston CCUS-2023 and would be good to touch base. As part of our Harbour Energy CCS development started in 2021 we have incorporated a CO2 EOS that can handle impurities for CCUS applications into our transient thermal tubular stress analysis model (PERIFOR)




  • 6.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-18-2023 08:54 AM

    Looking forward to it, John. I will connect over linkedin/whatsapp. 




  • 7.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-19-2023 11:28 PM

    Thank you John.




  • 8.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-19-2023 11:28 PM

    Thank you, appreciate receiving some helpful info.




  • 9.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-18-2023 09:51 AM

    At the wellhead injection pressures you referenced there could be significant changes in CO2 density at temperatures above 25 deg C




  • 10.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-19-2023 09:33 AM

    large changes in CO2 density will have a significant effect on the results of nodal analysis



    ------------------------------
    Alexander Lamar
    Senior Reservoir Engineer, CapturePoint LLC
    CapturePoint is currently earning 45Q Tax Credits on ~1.0 million tons per year of sequestered CO2
    CapturePoint is currently developing Class VI injection sites in Colorado, Kansas, Louisiana, Oklahoma, Mississippi, and Texas
    www.capturepointllc.com
    ------------------------------



  • 11.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-19-2023 11:29 PM

    Thank you Lamar.




  • 12.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-20-2023 01:11 AM

    Cont.. 

    This may include careful consideration of materials, thicknesses, and configurations to minimize areas of stress concentration that could lead to failure.

    In summary, designing down hole completion and tubulars metallurgy for a CO2 injection well requires careful consideration of the corrosive nature of CO2 gas and the high pressure of the injection. Materials such as high-strength, corrosion-resistant steel, nickel alloys, and ceramic coatings may be used, and special seals, gaskets, and cement additives may be required. The design should aim to create a robust and reliable system that can withstand the challenging conditions of CO2 injection.



    ------------------------------
    Amjad Saeed Yazdanie
    Consultant Business upstream
    AVANT Gulf Consulting WLL
    Engineering & Energy

    Yazdanie@avantengineering.com
    18324178656
    ------------------------------



  • 13.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-20-2023 12:09 PM

    In your earlier questions you asked whether carbon steel can be used for the dehydrated CO2. We are involved with at least 12 CCS injection projects from a metallurgy and corrosion standpoint and the answer is yes for those components not exposed to the saline aquifer. Assuming you have great confidence you can consistently maintain water free injection. In cases where water drops out as a free liquid the pH will be 3 and corrosion of steel will be very high. For casing, tubing, packers, etc, exposed to the saline reservoir a corrosion resistant alloy (CRA) is needed and the choice requires careful analysis of the specific impurities in the CO2 and the water compostion of the aquifer. We have performed labortory corrosion tests and many CRAs are unsuitable, especially 13Cr. Therefore engage a metallurgy/corrosion expert early because the costs of such completions can be quite high. 



    ------------------------------
    Bruce Craig
    Stress Engineering Services
    Bruce.Craig@stress.com
    ------------------------------



  • 14.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-20-2023 01:56 PM

    Great insight Bruce. 
    We are currently testing material samples for a client in Asia Pacific for 22Cr BHA. Do you perform these tests under triaxial loads or mainly focused on impurities in CO2 and worst case exposure scenarios? 
    I believe our team in Houston is in touch with Stress for many Premium Connection Qualification tests at Stress Engineering? 
    Have you been testing API5C5 CAL IV tested connections for CCS specific load scenarios? 




  • 15.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-18-2023 09:53 AM

    HI Sahir - Matteo Loizzo is absolutely correct: in modelling CO2 in the wellbore the choice of EOS is critical. The challenge is knowing which, if any, of those available in commercial software is the best for your stream. Phase change (in the model you've used) is one possible explanation for the sensitivity of gas rate to pressure. If you can generate the phase envelope being used by your model (and if you can't, you have a black box!) you can compare this with a standard for pure CO2 (or your own PVT for an industrial stream).

    Our experience is that IF the fluid remains in the dense phase as Matteo suggests current models are OK. But if you move out of this phase (for example, stopping injection into a depleted reservoir) the effect on temperature in the wellbore may be very significant. 



    ------------------------------
    Simon Glover
    Altus Well Experts Inc.
    sglover@altuswellexperts.com
    ------------------------------



  • 16.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-19-2023 11:27 PM

    Thank you Simon




  • 17.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-20-2023 01:08 AM

    Dear Inam, 

    The designing down hole completion and tubulars metallurgy for a CO2 injection well, it is important to consider the high pressure and corrosive nature of the CO2 gas. Here are some potential options for metallurgy materials and design:

    1. Tubulars: Depending on the depth and pressure of the well, steel casing may be used to line the wellbore. In this case, a high-strength, corrosion-resistant steel such as duplex stainless steel or high-chromium steel would be recommended.

    2. Completion equipment: For components such as valves, pumps, and other equipment, materials such as nickel alloys or ceramic coatings may be used to reduce the risk of corrosion. In addition, special seals and gaskets rated for high temperature and pressure may be required.

    3. Cement: The cement used to seal the wellbore should be rated for high CO2 exposure and have good mechanical properties to withstand the high pressure of the injection. Special additives such as silica fume or fly ash may be added to improve the cement's ability to resist CO2 corrosion.

    4. Design: The wellbore and components should be designed to withstand the high pressure and high corrosive nature of gas being injected. 



    ------------------------------
    Amjad Saeed Yazdanie
    Consultant Business upstream
    AVANT Gulf Consulting WLL
    Engineering & Energy

    Yazdanie@avantengineering.com
    18324178656
    ------------------------------



  • 18.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-24-2023 05:01 AM

    Dear Sahir,
    I'm not a well engineer, but maybe I can share a few things that may be of help:
    With the well design also keep in mind the abandonment
    Depending on the source of CO2, different contaminations can be present that can be corrosive by themselves or can cause a dropout of water (which can cause a corrosive liquid)
    Are you injecting in an aquifer, depleted gas reservoir, oil reservoir? Phase behaviour can play an important role and has a significant impact on the temperature, especially if you go through the 2-phase region (liquid+vapour). For example, we are also looking at the possibility of freezing of annular fluids, hydrates, thermal fracturing, etc.
    The well design can have a significant impact on the operating envelope of your well, so this is another important consideration.
    Good luck!
    Kind regards,
    Joop



    ------------------------------
    Joop de Kok
    Senior Reservoir Engineer CCUS
    EBN B.V.
    ------------------------------



  • 19.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-25-2023 01:28 AM
    Typical phase diagram for CO2. CCS injection usually happens in the supercritical fluid area
    Here is the CO2 phase diagram. Injection for CCS usually happens in the lower left quadrant of the supercritical area, which explains the nice rate increase. CO2 is especially a great injection medium for miscible flooding EOR, so this opportunity should be sought for any CCS project.



  • 20.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-25-2023 11:38 PM

    Thank you Robert.




  • 21.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 07-03-2023 03:41 AM

    Hi, I notice on another thread it is mentioned that EOR can not be considered as part of SMRS - can you comment please?

    • SMRS (Storage Resource Management System) is only applicable to Brine or depleted reservoirs and hence EOR using CO2 is not considered part of this SMRS classification.




    ------------------------------
    Paul Hazel Welltec Inc phazel@welltec.com
    ------------------------------



  • 22.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 07-03-2023 04:32 AM

    Well, let us put it this way. I am a practical person, and real world feasibility and economics have driven everything I did in my career.  I also think that through my practical work in many parts of this world I have done more actual environmental protection than most people could even dream of, especially the green absolutists.
    Plus, what is not really economic will not be done "sustainably": The fact is that already many EOR projects struggle with economics: Now if you add (partial) CO2 sequestration to them, as you do with a CO2 miscible flooding project, you create a double win, where one part supports the other, and you can do both, better EOR and economically feasible CO2 deposition. Let us put it gently, I do not agree with absolutistic and ideological viewpoints, like unfortunately expressed in the SMRS document, where a rather small group of zealots were able to publish a document I am sure a large number of our members do not agree with. Bu then, I also believe the biggest catastrophic threat to our human living environment is nuclear war, not "climate change".

    If something has to be ideologically pure, and only the perfect is accepted, it likely will never be done, or worse, end in "rivers of blood". Our Society of Petroleum Engineers should not be an "end oil" NGO, but should rather ensure and promote world Hydrocarbon supply as THE abundant and affordable energy form that enables 95% of the world population to be alive today, and has allowed a poverty - and hunger-reduction in this world like never before in human history. So our society should follow more Michael Economides and Alex Epstein, and less Al Gore and Greta Thunberg. So if this Society's published guidelines fail to include CO2 miscible flooding as one of the methods, it is up to the individual operator to convince the host Gov regulator that it is "better than nothing", i.e. the right thing to do. That is the true engineer's challenge. Not waiting for others to regulate, and then just follow regulations.




  • 23.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-25-2023 03:14 AM

    Dear Sahir

    just adding to Joop's response (I am also not a WE myself). The presence of impurities in the CO2 (e.g. nitrogen, methane, hydrogen, others) can have a very large impact on the phase envelop even when the amount of impurity is very small. This is important when considering potential phase changes or multi-phase flow in well and pipeline.

    As you mention Utilisation, i.e. CCUS and may be considering EOR, then those impurities will also affect miscibility (in the reservoir).

    A search on OnePetro will direct you to dozens of papers in the last 2-3 years.

    All the best!

    Suzanne



    ------------------------------
    Suzanne Hurter
    Senior Scientist Specialist CCS
    TNO
    The Netherlands
    ------------------------------



  • 24.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-25-2023 11:33 PM

    Thank you Suzanne.




  • 25.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-25-2023 05:16 PM

    While the phase envelope posted by Robert looks straightforward, finding a computationally stable model for CO2 phase behaviour in the wellbore is not. As noted by Suzanne Hurter, this challenge is increased by the presence of any impurities, which are likely be present in 'industrial' CO2. We've found very significant temperature changes to be predicted, as mentioned by Joop de Kok. We're not convinced any of the current EOS's properly capture this behaviour, hence our efforts to develop a promising alternative.



    ------------------------------
    Simon Glover
    Altus Well Experts Inc.
    sglover@altuswellexperts.com
    ------------------------------



  • 26.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-25-2023 10:13 PM

    Designing a CO2 injection well and its tubular metallurgy requires several key considerations before any planning or SCM is initiated. 

    1. Reservoir properties: Knowledge of reservoir properties is essential to determine the depth, pressure, and temperature range for well design. Important factors to consider include the rock lithology, porosity, permeability, rock compressibility and pressures.

    2. Well casing: Stainless steel or carbon steel casing can be used in CO2 injection wells, but stainless steel is recommended due to its better resistance to corrosive environments and long time savings. The casing size should be selected based on the pressure and temperature conditions of the reservoir.

    3. Cementing: High-quality cementing is required for at-least last two casings,  the casing string to be protected from any potential  CO2 gas leaks behind the casing and to avoid the well from potential CO2 leaks in long time operations.The cement slurry should be designed with additives that improve bonding, prevent gas migration, and resist high-pressure environments.

    4. Tubing: The selection of tubing for CO2 injection will depend on the CO2 concentration and pressure conditions. Generally, nickel-chromium alloys are recommended for high CO2 concentrations, while carbon steel is suitable for lower CO2 concentrations.

    5. Couplings and fittings: Corrosion-resistant couplings and fittings are essential for preventing CO2 leaks. Materials such as nickel-based alloys are recommended for corrosive environments. 

    6. Corrosion protection: Several corrosion protection strategies can be used to safeguard against CO2-induced corrosion, including coatings, anodic and cathodic protection, and corrosion inhibitors.

    Overall, designing a CO2 injection well and its tubular metallurgy requires a thorough understanding of the reservoir properties of the existing producing wells where gas containing CO2 which is being separated through Amine processing units, the processed gas containing CO2 its compositional analysis and selection of materials that can withstand the corrosive environments associated with CO2 injection. Proper well construction and maintenance are essential to ensure long-term well integrity and successful CO2 injection operations.



    ------------------------------
    Amjad Saeed Yazdanie
    Consultant Business upstream
    AVANT Gulf Consulting WLL
    Engineering & Energy

    Yazdanie@avantengineering.com
    18324178656
    ------------------------------



  • 27.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 07-03-2023 04:06 AM

    Some further thoughts on completion aspects:

    Don't forget it is an injection well, that means that any corrosion products end up at the formation face, and thus will reduce permeability. So while a "corrosion allowance" via thick-walled carbon steel tubing may be a strategy for producing wells with a clear limited service life, it is not a good idea for matrix injectors.

    So looking at materials, it all depends on CO2 partial pressure. Contrary to what may be permissible for surface lines, it also should not be assumed that the system always will be dry (water-free), which was in some areas, like Northern Germany, an excellent way of corrosion protection in highly sour gas fields. And being a disposal well, no assumption on the (lack of) impurities should be made.

    One thing we learned in the big bore gas producers in the South China Sea is that the thermal expansion and contraction of a well depending on the operating state is the key factor for connection integrity failure. Thus selecting a thread-sealing connection like Hydril 563 is preferable over any shoulder sealing arrangement.

    A good place to start is the API report on CO2 injection wells, because it "ain't nothing new" for our business, having successfully drilled, completed and operated over decades tens of thousands of CO2 injector wells for EOR: https://www.api.org/~/media/files/ehs/climate-change/summary-carbon-dioxide-enhanced-oil-recovery-well-tech.pdf

    So as a conclusion, select a material where you can be sure that no parts of the material will end up at the formation interface, and consider not only corrosion and erosion, but also expansion and contraction due to pressure and thermal effects.




  • 28.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-25-2023 11:33 PM

    Thank you Joop.




  • 29.  RE: Requirement for designing Well Completion for CCUS project

    Posted 04-27-2023 08:40 AM
    Edited by Mark Wagner 04-27-2023 08:51 AM

    Sahir,

    I am currently engaged in certifying active Carbon Capture Utilization and Storage (CCUS) EOR projects worldwide in accordance with ISO 27916:2019 (or ISO 27914:2017 for geological storage in saline reservoirs, which sets forth more detailed design recommendations than ISO 27916). Maintaining tubular integrity is crucial, and there are several compliant solutions to achieve this. While the technical suggestions provided so far are sound, it is also important to consider the economic implications of your decisions.

    Operators have successfully maintained containment compliance using internally coated carbon steel tubulars, non-IC tubulars with corrosion inhibitors, and CRA installations. To determine the optimal solution for your project, you must consider various factors such as the composition and phase properties of the injectant, project duration, workover frequency, and tubular handling programs. It is critical to avoid overdesigning and selecting the most expensive casing/tubing/packer and wellhead equipment. Such decisions could lead to unnecessary costs and may not be required for certification purposes.

    Therefore, I suggest that in addition to the guidance given herein, you carefully evaluate economic aspects of your project to make informed decisions that meet both certification requirements and economic feasibility.

    I rely on a risk-based approach using Monte Carlo simulations in UnRiskIT®.  By utilizing this approach, I account for the unique aspects of each installation, which can be challenging for traditional selection methods. Additionally, selecting a system using a non-deterministic method addresses both operational and managerial concerns. The stochastic nature of Monte Carlo simulations ensures that uncertainties and variations in the inputs are taken into account, providing a more accurate picture of the potential outcomes. This approach allows for a more comprehensive analysis of the risks associated with each system, enabling you to make informed decisions that minimize risk and maximize value.